Order 0: OSH Park 4-layer RF demo and fab-model coupons

Status: pre-registration in preparation. Nothing has been uploaded, ordered or measured. The boards, predictions and criteria on these pages are drafts until the pre-registration release (below) is published; after that, predictions and criteria are never edited, and results are added as new commits next to them, misses included.

Order 0 is a small OSH Park 4-layer order that carries two things on one lot:

  1. Fab-model coupons that measure what OSH Park actually builds (dielectric constant and loss of the prepreg and core, heights, copper, etch, solder mask) with a two-port VNA and multiline TRL, using yapnr’s coupon extraction (user guide).

  2. Microstrip designs made by yapnr’s RF optimizer (a 3-port power divider on each of two cross-sections), measured against their own pre-registered simulations and against a textbook design built the way a designer would, with the same launches and the same pass/fail table.

The QR code on the boards’ tag stick points here.

The three uploads

All three are OSH Park standard 4-layer, FR408HR (the EM528 alternate is covered by the same models), 1.6 mm, ENIG, purple mask, 3 copies each, one frameless outline per upload: the sticks are separated by 2.54 mm milled slots and held by OSH Park’s suggested mouse-bite tabs, at least two per stick, only on edges that carry no connector (a 2-port stick’s long sides, a 3-port demo’s fourth edge), so every launch edge is a clean milled edge. Every port is a Cinch 142-0701-851 edge-launch SMA. Costs are OSH Park’s standard 4-layer price, $10 per square inch of the bounding rectangle, for 3 copies.

Upload

Contents

Size

Cost

SMAs per copy

O0-M

the thin-microstrip (region M) coupons, R1, A16, A04R, the tag

120.1 × 144.3 mm, 26.9 sq in

$269

33

O0-W

the thick-microstrip (region W) calibration set, R1t, D2 (d2-star-sched), QR B15

54.0 × 158.7 mm, 13.3 sq in

$133

16

O0-D

the D1 window (d1-star, re-optimized under the fixed corner-gap DRC), an R1 copy, a thru, a 9 mm and a 30 mm line, QR stick A15

118.2 × 50.0 mm, 9.16 sq in

$91.57

12

O0-W carries D2’s nearest miss, d2-star-sched (label 03b7d938), as a pre-registered design that misses its spec, by the owner default recorded in the pre-registration (the owner confirms or overrides it before the release), and the small QR stick B15 to predictions/D2. Its Gerber zip’s sha256 is in fab/O0-W.sha256.

D1 passed (d1-star, label O0 D1 divider-osh-m 7e070ca8, superseding part 2’s ad20e643): the part 2 export reproduced two 0.100 mm corner-gap violations against OSH Park’s 0.127 mm rule under PR #53’s fixed exact-corner-gap DRC, so D1 was re-optimized from the same four formulations under that fixed checker (predictions/D1-d1c); d1-star is again the only formulation that passes coarse/fine/finer, now with a DRC-clean export (134 repaired pixels, 24 floating islands, vs 30/14 under the old checker). O0-D is regenerated with YAPNR_KICAD_CLI=<headless kicad-cli> python -m yapnr.rf.coupons generate --stackup OSHPARK-4L-FR408HR --upload D --out examples/rf-coupons/order0/O0-D: KiCad DRC 0 violations, 0 unconnected (10.0.6); yapnr fab build 0 errors (2 pre-existing informational warnings: merged non-plated drill file, stackup thickness, the same pattern O0-W’s build has). Its Gerber zip’s sha256 is in fab/O0-D.sha256.

Two solvers carry a prediction for this D1, compared like for like on nominal FR408HR: yapnr.rf’s own FDTD on M-nom puts it at the −20 dB |S11| spec line (−19.70 / −20.02 / −20.05 dB coarse / fine / finer; it passes the selection criteria with a 0.282 dB margin, and −20.77 dB on its M-eq design substrate), and an independent openEMS 0.37 run (43 µm copper, 0.05 mm mesh) predicts a 2.9 dB miss (−17.10 dB), essentially part 2’s finding on the old export; the two agree on |S21| within 0.14 dB. A third, Palace (FEM), was not run for D1 or R1 this round: this workflow’s separate $8 GCP cap left too little margin after the resubmission and validation campaigns, and Palace also needs a new divider-shaped planar adapter; open item for a follow-up. Details, campaign ids and the three-solver table are in predictions/D1-d1c/README.md.

The KiCad projects, catalogues and DRC results are in examples/rf-coupons/order0/.

O0-M, the top copper, mask openings (light) and silkscreen as KiCad renders them: one outline,the sticks held by tabs with three mouse-bite holes each side

O0-W: the W calibration set, R1t, the QR stick B15 and D2 (d2-star-sched) in its window

O0-D: the filled D1 window (, 7e070ca8), R1, the thru and lines, and QR stick A15, turned 90°

Cross-sections

Region

Signal over

Dielectric

50 Ω line

L1 ground kept away

Stick width

M

L1 over In1.Cu

0.200 mm FR408HR prepreg

0.40 mm (4 pixels of the optimizer’s 0.10 mm grid)

1.0 mm (5 h)

12 mm

W

L1 over B.Cu, In1/In2 removed

0.200 + 0.991 + 0.200 mm

3.0 mm (6 pixels of 0.50 mm)

4.2 mm (3 h)

16 mm

The solder mask is open over all RF copper and its keep-away (the optimizer has no mask model), with 0.2 mm mask dams at the connector pads; one coupon (A10) keeps the mask on.

O0-M sticks

Stick

Structure

Size (mm)

What it determines

A01

thru: two launch halves (also the launch-only 2x-thru)

20 × 12

mTRL thru; launch quality and repeatability

A02-A05

M lines, ΔL 4.5, 13, 30, 70 mm

24.5-90 × 12

γ(f): εeff and loss

A06

reflect: the line open at both reference planes

30 × 12

mTRL reflect

A07

verification line, ΔL 21 mm

41 × 12

residual calibration error

A08, A09

width set: 0.28 and 0.56 mm over 30 mm

50 × 12

Z0(w), α(w): etch, height, εr, the copper-thickness bias

A10

the 0.40 mm line under mask over 30 mm

50 × 12

mask Dk × thickness: OSH Park’s default against mask-open

A11

ring, fed directly, the feeds a quarter turn apart (notches at n = 1 and 3: 1.92 and 5.79 GHz)

56 × 36

held out: εeff

A12

open λ/4 stub, notch at 5.5 GHz, on a 15 mm line

35 × 19

held out: the open-end and T-junction models

A14

30 mm line with a shunt 0402 100 Ω 5 mm from RP1

50 × 12

switch terms (both orientations)

A15

4-wire meanders on L1 (0.20 × 200 mm, 0.50 × 250 mm), microsection lines, QR and tag

68 × 24

w·t and etch; microsection; this page

A16

6 mm and 12 mm square pads, each at the reference plane of a launch

50 × 16

h (and so the absolute Z0) from C at 0.1-1 GHz

A04R

A04 turned 90°

12 × 50

glass-weave direction

R1

textbook divider: T-junction + λ/4 35.36 Ω transformer [Pozar §7.2, §5.5]

30 × 38

the reference for D1

O0-W sticks

Stick

Structure

Size (mm)

What it determines

B01-B04

W thru and lines, ΔL 5, 14, 34 mm

20-54 × 16

γ(f) of W: the core’s Dk, which region M cannot see

B05

reflect, open at both reference planes

30 × 16

mTRL reflect

R1t

the textbook divider on W

33 × 50

the reference for D2

D2

the optimizer’s thick divider d2-star-sched (20 × 24 mm window), feeds, keep-away

40 × 52

D2: a pre-registered miss of its spec (owner default)

B15

QR to predictions/D2 and the tag text

25 × 25

this page

O0-D sticks

Stick

Structure

Size (mm)

What it determines

D1

the optimizer’s thin divider (12 × 15 mm, d1-star, label 7e070ca8), feeds and keep-away

29 × 41

the headline demo (at the spec line on yapnr.rf, misses on openEMS)

A15

small QR label stick to predictions/D1-d1c

25 × 25

this page

R1

a copy of O0-M’s R1

30 × 38

D1 and a reference on one lot

A01, A20, A04

thru and lines ΔL 9 and 30 mm

20, 29, 50 × 12

this lot’s εeff, loss and relative Z0 (the 9 mm line covers 5-6 GHz)

The demos and their references

Demo

Specification

Window

Reference

D1 (O0-D)

4.25-5.75 GHz: |S11| ≤ −20 dB, |S21|, |S31| ≥ −3.4 dB (confirmed by run 0b)

region M, 12 × 15 mm, ports W / N / S

R1: arm 0.70 × 9.0 mm (9.2 mm to the junction centre)

D2 (O0-W)

the same

region W, 20 × 24 mm, ports W / N / S

R1t: arm 5.0 × 9.25 mm (10.75 mm to the centre)

Each demo port has exactly the coupons’ launch (10 mm from the milled edge to its reference plane) and a straight feed (3 mm on M, 4 mm on W) to the window, so the comparison plane is the optimizer’s own port plane. No other L1 copper lies within 1.0 mm (M) or 4.2 mm (W) of a window.

R1 and R1t are drawn as a designer would: the arm is the 2D-solved width nearest the ideal transformer impedance, a quarter wave long at 5.0 GHz counted from the T-junction’s reference plane, which lies 0.37 mm (M) and 2.18 mm (W) beyond the output line’s centre line (Hammerstad’s T-junction model). Counted to the centre line instead, R1 would sit 4 % and R1t 25 % high in frequency. Every edge lies on the grid the optimizer’s FDTD predicts them on: 0.05 mm (M) and 0.25 mm (W), its second refinement (R1’s 0.70 mm arm cannot be centred on the 0.10 mm grid).

Pages

  • Pre-registration: what is frozen before upload, the draft criteria and the analysis order.

  • Measurement procedure: the LibreVNA set-up, the two-tier calibration and the sequence per copy.

  • Predictions: the coupons’ expected S-parameters on FR408HR and EM528, and the places for D1 and D2.

  • Demos: D1’s and D2’s specs, substrates (thickness-equivalent) and formulations, the references’ forward runs, and run 0b (the solver’s loss correction and the |S21| criterion).

Regenerating

YAPNR_KICAD_CLI=<headless kicad-cli> python -m yapnr.rf.coupons generate \
    --stackup OSHPARK-4L-FR408HR --upload M --out examples/rf-coupons/order0/O0-M
python -m yapnr.rf.coupons expected --stackup OSHPARK-4L-FR408HR --upload M \
    --out docs/rf/order0/predictions/coupons/O0-M
yapnr fab check examples/rf-coupons/order0/O0-M/O0-M.kicad_pcb --vendor oshpark \
    --profile oshpark-4l --stackup oshpark-4l-fr408hr

(and --upload W, --upload D).