openEMS predictions (D-O0-13a), as found¶
D1 rows below are for part 2’s superseded D1 export (
ad20e643). The shipped D1 (7e070ca8) has its own openEMS result in D1-d1c; R1’s rows still apply.
The independent 3D prediction of D1 and R1 (43 µm copper on the nominal FR408HR stack, two
meshes; models and method in ../../openems/), loss-corrected like the
yapnr.rf arm, and its comparison with yapnr.rf (comparison.json). The launch
sticks A01 and A04 are in ../../openems/runs/ and the sticks block of
comparison.json.
d1-openems-r05-loss-corrected.s3p,d1-openems-r025-loss-corrected.s3p: D1 (d1-star, labelO0 D1 divider-osh-m ad20e643) at 0.05 and 0.025 mm in the plane.r1-openems-r05-loss-corrected.s3p,r1-openems-r025-loss-corrected.s3p: R1, the same.
What the two solvers predict (4.25-5.75 GHz, loss-corrected)¶
Design |
Solver |
Worst |S11| |
Worst |S21|, |S31| |
In-band |S11| minimum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
D1 |
yapnr.rf (M-eq) |
−20.90 dB |
−3.306 dB |
4.93 GHz |
D1 |
openEMS, 0.05 mm |
−17.42 dB |
−3.322 dB |
5.48 GHz |
D1 |
openEMS, 0.025 mm |
−18.17 dB |
−3.313 dB |
5.40 GHz |
R1 |
yapnr.rf (M-eq) |
−21.34 dB |
−3.285 dB |
5.04 GHz |
R1 |
openEMS, 0.05 mm |
−19.69 dB |
−3.295 dB |
5.15 GHz |
R1 |
openEMS, 0.025 mm |
−20.47 dB |
−3.294 dB |
5.11 GHz |
The two agree on transmission (max |ΔS21| 0.083 dB on D1, 0.024 dB on R1) and disagree on D1’s match. openEMS predicts that D1 does not meet the −20 dB |S11| spec (a 2.7-3.5 dB miss) and that its in-band |S11| minimum sits 9.5-11.1 % above yapnr.rf’s, outside the ±1.5 % “agrees” row; yapnr.rf predicts a pass. On R1 the gap is smaller (0.9-1.7 dB, minimum +1.3-2.0 %), and the finer openEMS mesh moves both designs towards yapnr.rf. The leading suspect is the thickness-equivalent substrate, fitted on an isolated line, which cannot represent the sidewall coupling across D1’s 14 floating islands (copper thickness / gap ≈ 0.22); this is not established. Both are predictions made before fabrication; neither is preferred here. The criteria compare the measurement with the yapnr.rf prediction (pre-registration); the openEMS numbers are reported next to it as a registered alternative.